Confessions of a pagan farmer

I'd go with truck "B", although I don't agree with your checkbox options for why, so didn't select any. Higher tow rating, smaller, more maneuverable, and larger bed are all good reasons. A much lesser reason would be you sound rather attached to the old one... even if it's somehow a metaphor for aspects of your life, the map isn't the territory. It's just a truck, my $.02 is to go for the more sensible one. Not fitting in the barn cellar, well, would lowering the suspension cause other problems?